Discover more from Erick Erickson's Show Notes
Cleaning Up the Right
A number of years ago, I noted a connection between various Republican consultants and the incestuous ties within political campaigns. The GOP has a problem with a lot of consultants. They get paid commissions whether a candidate wins or loses. They get commissions from most parts of a campaign business and, interestingly, do not invest in parts that do not pay commissions. It is time for action.
On the consultant front, here in Georgia, it is not just that Raphael Warnock outspent Herschel Walker. It is how Warnock outspent Walker. In 2021, Warnock had over seventy varieties of streaming ads for digital services. The Republicans had two. This time, again, Warnock more precisely targeted various voters online than the GOP did. One will not be surprised to discover how little consultants make off digital advertising.
In 2008 and 2012, Barack Obama brought his consulting team in house, paid them salaries, and gave them benefits. The GOP continued to rely on outside consultants who drew commissions and often worked multiple candidates. Obama hired some of the best and had them totally committed to him. The GOP hired the freelancers who freelanced and made commissions. Obama got better deals because his consultants were in house, not marking up their work for commissions.
There really are no commissions for early voting ground games. The GOP consultants have focused on media ad buys, mail pieces, and not critical operations for vote mobilization. That must change for the GOP to win. Either the consultants need to rethink or the GOP needs better consultants.
Concurrently, the Republican National Committee could use a shake up. Ronna McDaniel has been chair since 2017. She has served longer than all but one RNC Chair, her predecessor. In her time, she has had no good election cycles. In fact, McDaniel has only had losing election cycles, unless one counts a bare win of the House of Representatives this year as her big victory. No RNC Chair in the history of the RNC has performed over time as badly as her. They were all replaced or resigned after losses. She has hung on like kudzu, the seemingly indestructible invasive species of the South.
The committeemen and women of the RNC have seemingly decided they will stick with the losing Chair and all that entails, including the same consultants and contracts and flows of money. There is no incentive to shake things up when the status quo benefits. Loss, after all, generates profit too. Change requires courage.
One other area the right as a whole, and not just the Republican Party, must take on is the echo chamber of unaccomplishment. Many on the right have long argued that many of the loudest voices on the left who demand to shape society are spectacularly insulated from the world around them due to money, career paths, living arrangements, and more.
Last week, an urban planning warrior denounced the need for in-unit washers and dryers. He insisted no one ever needed to do laundry every day and once a week or two at a laundromat should be fine. He is a single childless twenty-something. He has no lived experience.
I do not think one must be in a demographic to opine on that demographic. A man should be as able to discuss issues related to women as women can with men. Civilians should be able to make informed opinions and policy decisions about the military, even with a lack of service. But credentials also should not be substituted for a lived life.
Like with the left, parts of the right are increasingly being held captive to the voices and opinions of spectacularly unaccomplished young men and women with brash Twitter personalities hiding their lack of lived lives. We probably should not be trying to set policies related to the working class based on the musings of a pampered progressive brat or of a pampered right-winger subsidized by dad. Nor should we set public policy by people who have only ever lived a political life. Unfortunately, both sides are more and more catering to the least accomplished, loudest voices whose only work experience is a political cause.