We Already Have the Data. Roe Reversal Won't Help the Democrats
I have been a long-time supporter of Alliance Defending Freedom. ADF assists people who have Christian conservative worldviews with legal representation from city councils to the United States Supreme Court.
Additionally, ADF trains lawyers and pundits on how to talk about complex legal issues in easy-to-understand ways. I support ADF with my giving and hope you will too. Right now they have a donor willing to match your donations. You can give at adflegal.org/erickson
Yesterday, Politico reported on the topic. Democrats and their media echo chamber have long posited that real threats to Roe would mobilize Democrat turnout. Republican consultants often fret the same. The Republican consultants afraid to undo Roe is frankly one reason we have a populist uprising on the right. The establishment got power and generally refused to use it till Trump forced them.
All one needs to know is the name Ed Stezler. He is a State Representative and authored the fetal heartbeat law in Georgia. His district had trended Democrat. Stacey Abrams won it in 2018 and he barely hung. In 2020, after the Georgia legislature passed Ed’s bill, he became the most highly targeted state house Republican in America. Democrats from across the nation poured money into beating Ed. They made their entire campaign about abortion. They targeted voters. They sent door knockers. They had phone banks. They had celebrities. They outspent Ed Setzler and the Republicans.
Biden beat Trump in his district. The Democrats picked up both Senate seats in his district. Ed won with 50.5% of the vote. Making the race against him about abortion failed.
In Texas, Abortion Barbie a/k/a Wendy Davis, ran for both Governor and Congress. She tried to run on other issues, but had defined herself on abortion as the abortion candidate. Both times, the abortion candidate lost.
In Virginia, Terry McAuliffe ran hard on the issue of abortion and what the GOP might do. But exit polling showed voters who cared about the issue more than any other wound up leaning Youngkin.
In 2020, with the United States Supreme Court literally on the line in a 4-4 split with Scalia’s seat in the balance, Trump won.
Abortion is an issue that excites the already excited progressive base. It excites the media because the media leans left and women in the press are some of the biggest abortion advocates in the nation. Pro-abortion coverage gets disproportionate airtime. But it does not really move the needle even in swing seats like Ed Setzler’s seat in Georgia.
Over the next year, we will get a ton of unbalanced and unreasonable media coverage that the threat to Roe will help the Democrats. The reality is that most swing states and red states already have restricted Roe so in the daily lived lives of Americans, abortion is not an issue. Progressive states where Roe really matters have already locked in abortion rights legislatively. So they won’t be impacted either.
Roe plays well with the women on CNN and MSNBC and the progressives who already live in states where they will have abortion on demand till Kingdom come. It doesn’t play as a deciding factor anywhere else. We have ample data on this point despite Democrat claims and media hysteria.